Worldwide Web WorldTribune.com
  • Obama sought to limit independent probes of Fort Hood shooting
  • U.S. to seize Iran properties said to channel funds for WMD programs
  • China, DPRK out-maneuver Obama before his Asia trip even begins
  • China could use its microchips to penetrate U.S. weapons systems

  •   Commentary . . .


    Lev Navrozov Archive
    Tuesday, June 19, 2007

    Hitler II: Delegating genocide

    Lev Navrozov emigrated from the Soviet Union in 1972 He settled in New York City where he quickly learned that there was no market for his eloquent and powerful English language attacks on the Soviet Union. To this day, he writes without fear or favor or the conventions of polite society. He chaired the "Alternative to the New York Times Committee" in 1980, challenged the editors of the New York Times to a debate (which they declined) and became a columnist for the New York City Tribune. His columns are today read in both English and Russian.

    In this Part 2, following Part 1, posted last week, I will continue to discuss readers' e-mails in response to my column, "Stupidity, Not Evil, Brought Hitler Into Power."

    The next e-mail of June 1 was bitterly hostile to me. The author (who named himself Aikon) believes that if Hitler had a visceral hatred of Jews, he was a monstrous criminal. But if he ordered his subordinates to annihilate millions of Jews so that his subordinates could not expect anything but the death sentence even if they had betrayed him to the English-speaking, then I whitewash Hitler, according to Aikon!

    Aikon is full of irony: "Stalin loved the Kulaks, too. Perhaps deported and murdered them en mass as merely a distracting PR campaign."

    Also In This Edition

    NORTHEAST ASIA:

    U.S. advisory panel warns of rampant Chinese spying

    Mideast / S. Asia:

    Hizbullah included in Lebanon premier's new Cabinet

    AFRICA/EUROPE:

    Thousands cheer 20 years since fall of Berlin Wall

    Actually, in the 1920s, the "kulaks" (owners of private farms) were expected to "grow into socialism." But in the 1930s, Stalin needed hands for his "industrialization." Collective farms were organized to make farmers work as much and as cheaply as possible, and make many of them go to work at industrial enterprises under the same terms. What was Stalin to do with farmers who owned their profitable farms? To take the farms away from them! But those dispossessed farmers would create a large hostile class. Deport them!

    So, according to Aikon, Stalin loved the "kulaks" in the 1920s, but began to hate them in the 1930s. And this is what a criminal is: he hates his victims, and to imagine that one can kill millions of human beings without any personal hatred, but for his safety or other personal goals, is laughable according to Aikon. "How you collapse in intellectual respectability," Aikon exclaims.

    Well, to do away with my "intellectual respectability," let me add that in the last years of his life, Stalin (who died in 1953) decided to deport Jews, and many of them were summarily fired. Now, in the 1920s, an anti-Semitic remark was considered a crime, and Jews had privileges in the matriculation at higher schools.

    Will Aikon say that Stalin loved Jews in the 1920s, but came to hate them in the 1950s?

    No! Stalin was pushing his Russian nationalism (based on the Byzantine worship of the emperor as of God) to new extremes, and the deportation of Jews was in keeping with his new ambitions.

    Emson Smith's e-mail consists of two lines, but it is worth quoting:

    "Re ‘Stupidity brought Hitler to power.' Is it possible that stupidity will also bring Mr. and Mrs. Bill Clinton back to power? Just wondering."

    Kindest regards!

    Emson S., Vidalia, Georgia, The Sweet Onion City

    In 1938, Americans like Mr. and Mrs. Bill Clinton were sure that Hitler meant "peace in our time." Had not Hitler started a conventional war by invading Poland, etc., but "peacefully" allocated all available resources to the development of nuclear weapons and outstripped the U.S. Manhattan Project, the world would have been his. But before Hitler's nuclear bombs would begin to annihilate U.S. cities (unless and until the United States accepted unconditional surrender), dozens of millions of Americans no more and no less intelligent than Mr. and Mrs. Bill Clinton would disregard Germany (except as a trade partner) as they have disregarded and would disregard China (except as a trade partner). The only difference is that Hitler would have developed nuclear weapons, while China has been developing post-nuclear super weapons.

    One reservation is in place. When the dictators of China crushed the Tiananmen Square movement in 1989, Bill Clinton condemned the dictators' battle against their own unarmed people who were after a peaceful reform. Most U.S. top government officials say not what they consider right, but what is publicly good for them. It was considered good and proper to condemn the crushing of the Tiananmen Square movement. Later on, Bill Clinton forgot his condemnation as one forgets his necktie, no longer fashionable. Only Bill Clinton's smile never goes out of fashion, and certainly he smiled his eternal smile to the Chinese when they donated to his re-election for the second term.

    Wolfgang S.' e-mail cannot be answered adequately because it is more than a full page in length. He says that the effect of the Treaty of Versailles "is covered by your article in detail and this is covered rather nicely, I must say."

    So what is not "covered rather nicely"? You see, I "call Hitler not anti-Semitic."

    It is still widely believed that to kill six million Jews simply because they are Jews is not anti-Semitic. What is anti-Semitic is to hate Jews and, in particular, to kill them out of hatred.

    The e-mail from Brinton M. Jr. is, on the contrary, brief:

    Mr. Navrozov, Well done sir, spot on. I took a course in college called "Hitler's Germany," and many of the same points were touched. I'm a big WW2 history buff, since I had family members in both the US Army and the Army Air Corp. One relative had both the Silver Star, and the Bronze Star for bravery. Keep on telling the truth, and spread it to the ignorant. "Those that don't learn from history are doomed to repeat it."

    An even briefer e-mail from Ken B. requires my comment: "Sir: Your description of the ‘Blutkitt' does not comport with history. The murder of Jews in Russia by Germans began before Stalingrad. Ken Bowers."

    The "Blutkitt" was Hitler's decision, after the rout of his troops near Moscow in December 1941, to make his subordinates begin the annihilation of Jews on the industrial scale (recall the Wannsee Conference, which he did not attend since he pretended that he had nothing to do with its "final solution of the Jewish problem"). His subordinates should know that in case they would choose to betray him to the English-speaking to save their own lives, they would not escape the death sentence.

    On June 2, a reader who calls himself Ousoonersocal, e-mailed to me and five other persons my column "Stupidity, Not Evil, Brought Hitler Into Power."

    He says: "Lev, I have never heard such a far-fetched viewpoint."

    Well, when in the West there were internationally known and heard political thinkers, they expressed "far-fetched viewpoints," not platitudes. But who is an internationally known political thinker in the USA today, after the death of Sidney Hook, whom I had the honor to know personally?

    A few years ago, I learned that some British academic experts on Hitler's Germany contend that Hitler knew nothing about the industrial annihilation of Jews. Their conclusion? It was his subordinates who did it, but the blame was shifted onto the innocent Hitler. Perhaps no one has been heard or will be heard asking internationally this question: How was it possible that the dictator of Germany did not know about the transportation from 1942 to 1945 of millions of victims to the buildings, constructed to gas and then cremate them?


    Lev Navrozov can be reached by e-mail at navlev@cloud9.net.

    ">
    About Us     l    Contact Us     l    Geostrategy-Direct.com     l    East-Asia-Intel.com
    Copyright © 2007    East West Services, Inc.    All rights reserved.
    World Tribune.com is a publication of East West Services, Inc.