An outgoing Bush administration official said the decision by
then-Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon to withdraw from the Gaza Strip and
northern West Bank in 2005 marked the end of the nationalist ideology of the
ruling Likud Party. The official said Likud and the splinter Kadima have
adopted the positions of the left-wing Labor Party.
"You've had this evolution in Israeli politics where even Arik Sharon is
advocating a Palestinian state and territorial partition," former Assistant
Defense Secretary Peter Rodman said. "The most interesting phenomenon in
Israeli politics over the last decade or so is the old Likud Party adopting
the Labor Party position on territorial partition and on a Palestinian
state. This is an extraordinarily positive evolution in Israeli politics."
Rodman, responsible for Pentagon international security affairs from
2001 until February 2007, addressed the U.S. Army Strategic Studies
Institute's annual strategy conference on March 27. Rodman, who moved to the
Brookings Institution, said the United States has failed to exploit the
transformation of Israel's right-wing because of the Palestinian refusal to
recognize Israel.
"And the Palestinians elect a Hamas government that wants to go back to
the 1946 borders or God knows what their position," Rodman said. "This is
insane and suicidal, literally and figuratively for the Palestinians. This
is their choice. Right now, the diplomacy is frustrated because of who is
the
interlocutor."
A U.S. official said Rodman's assessment reflected that of most career
officers in both the Pentagon and State Department. The official said that
during the Bush administration, senior officials urged Secretary of State
Condoleezza Rice and President George Bush to support Sharon's plan for a
unilateral withdrawal from the Gaza Strip and northern West Bank.
"The overriding U.S. assessment continues to be that any Israeli
withdrawal is a positive development and bolsters U.S. influence in the Arab
world," the official said.
Rodman cited the sea change in Israeli politics over the last 35 years.
He recalled accompanying then-Secretary of State Henry Kissinger in shuttles
between Egypt and Israel. At the time, the former Pentagon official said,
angry Israelis, outraged by U.S. pressure on Israel to withdraw from the
Egypt's Sinai Peninsula, tried to overturn Kissinger's car.
Today, the Bush administration has sought to strengthen Palestinian
Authority Chairman Mahmoud Abbas in an effort to convince Palestinians to
recognize Israel, Rodman said. He said the United States was ready to
pressure Israel to accept any compromise with the Palestinians.
"We are trying to navigate through this and strengthen Abbas, and our
job
is to help him gain mastery over the Palestinian front so you get some
sensible compromise position," Rodman said. "The United States has shown
many times in the last 30 years that we are ready to use our influence with
Israel when there is some plausible compromise on the table. And we've done
that a number of times."