Report: Israelis lose nationalist fervor after serving in military
|
SPECIAL TO WORLD TRIBUNE.COM
Friday, April 27, 2007
TEL AVIV — Israelis shed their nationalistic ardor during military
service, a new study said.
A study by Haifa University said combat soldiers tend to become less
hawkish and more supportive of the need for territorial compromises with
Israel's Arab neighbors. The research was conducted over 3.5 years, and
found that most recruits enter the army with hawkish positions and abandon
them during service.
"Contrary to what would be expected, military service does not cause the
adoption of militaristic views," [Res.] Col. Zvika Barkai, a political
science instructor at Haifa University, said.
The research surveyed 490 male and female soldiers of every rank and in
every branch of the Israeli military. The soldiers were asked to respond to
the same set of questions at three different times -- before induction, six
months into their service and immediately following their release.
Researchers said the study was meant to determine whether the military
was politically neutral. They said that during the first six months soldiers
became more nationalistic, particularly during basic training, but abandoned
the sentiment as their service continued.
"These soldiers adopted more conciliatory views towards
minorities in general, and more specifically towards the Arab minority, and
experienced a greater change in their views about human rights than soldiers
who began their service with less extreme views," the study said. "Over
all, when political views did change during military service, they reverted
back to the original views after release, with the exception of combat
soldiers who maintained more dovish views following their release."
The study said officers were more prone than their soldiers to support
human rights and democracy. At the same time, women in the military were
said to become more nationalistic.
Barkai said the study could be used by the government to promote change
among non-Jewish Israelis, such as Druse and Muslims. He recommended that
Arabs be included in the military draft.
"Even taking into account that expanding the draft to include the
abovementioned groups may have a marginal or even negative effect on the
country's security, the latent national gains should be weighed against the
security issues -- not necessarily by the military," Barkai said.
Copyright © 2007 East West
Services, Inc.
|